WHY YOU MAY NOT WANT USE INSURANCE TO PAY FOR THERAPY
Wade Arnold, MDiv, PhD, LLC
If you’ve ever struggled with anxiety or depression, or just needed a little help to manage the stress in your life, mental health treatment may have been a life-saver. In fact, 42% of all Americans have seen a counselor at some point in their lives.
We know therapy works. What is less clear is how to pay for it. For those of us with insurance, it seems logical that we would use it for therapy. But that isn’t always the best idea. We’ve put together the top 9 reasons why you shouldn’t use insurance to pay for mental health treatment.
Why Using Insurance for Counseling Often Isn’t the Best Option (Especially for Couples)
If you’re thinking about counseling, using insurance probably feels like the obvious move.
You already pay for coverage. Counseling can be expensive. And in a season where life feels hard, the last thing you want is another big decision.
That reaction makes sense.
What most people don’t realize is that insurance doesn’t just pay for counseling—it quietly shapes how counseling works. And those limits can matter more than many people expect, especially if your goal is long-term change, not just short-term relief.
This isn’t an argument against therapy. It’s about understanding the system behind it so you can make an informed choice instead of defaulting to what seems easiest.
Insurance Was Designed for Medical Problems
Insurance works best when something is clearly wrong in a medical sense.
A broken bone. An infection. A surgery that solves a specific problem.
Emotional struggles, relationship tension, stress, grief, or feeling stuck don’t follow that model. They’re complex, personal, and often tied to life circumstances rather than illness.
But insurance requires counseling to fit a medical framework anyway—and that shapes everything that follows.
The Diagnosis Requirement Most People Don’t Think About
To bill insurance, a counselor must assign a mental health diagnosis. There’s no way around it.
That means experiences many people see as normal parts of being human—burnout, anxiety during a difficult season, relationship conflict, emotional overwhelm—often get labeled as disorders so the sessions can be covered.
Once assigned, that diagnosis becomes part of a permanent medical record.
Many people are surprised to learn this record can matter later, especially when applying for:
Life insurance
Disability insurance
Certain jobs or licenses
You may go in looking for clarity or support and walk out with a label you never expected or needed.
Counseling Becomes Less Private Than It Feels
Counseling still feels confidential—and in many ways it is—but insurance adds another layer.
Insurance companies can request documentation to confirm that treatment is “medically necessary.” Session notes must justify progress and continued care.
That changes how records are written. Language becomes more clinical. Nuance gets compressed. Personal context matters less than meeting criteria.
Most clients never see this side of the process, but it shapes the experience behind the scenes.
Insurance Controls the Pace of Care
Insurance typically sets limits on:
How many sessions are allowed
How often you can meet
How long treatment can continue
If you improve quickly, coverage may end. If you don’t improve on the expected timeline, coverage may also end.
That creates pressure for counseling to look productive on paper—even when real change takes time.
For many people, especially couples, meaningful progress is gradual. Trust, communication, and habits don’t change neatly on a schedule.
Couples Counseling Is Where Insurance Fits the Worst
Here’s a detail many couples don’t learn until they’re already in the room: insurance doesn’t recognize the relationship as the client.
To bill for couples counseling, one partner usually has to be diagnosed.
From the start, that shapes the dynamic. One person becomes “the patient,” even when both partners contribute to the problem.
That framing can quietly undermine the very thing couples counseling is meant to build: shared responsibility and teamwork.
Labels Can Create Imbalance in the Relationship
Even when handled carefully, diagnoses can slip into everyday conversations:
“You’re the anxious one.”
“This is your issue.”
“You’re the one in therapy.”
Over time, that can shift the tone of the relationship. Instead of two people working together, counseling can feel like one person is being managed or fixed.
For couples trying to rebuild trust or connection, that imbalance matters.
Insurance Discourages Preventive Help
Insurance usually covers counseling once things are clearly “bad enough.”
That means many couples wait too long—until resentment has built up, communication has broken down, or emotional distance feels entrenched—before seeking help.
Early, preventive support is rarely covered, even though it’s often the most effective.
Growth Isn’t the Goal—Symptom Reduction Is
Insurance pays for counseling to reduce symptoms, not to promote growth.
It doesn’t cover work aimed at:
Strengthening a healthy relationship
Improving communication skills
Clarifying shared goals
Building long-term emotional resilience
Yet these are often the very reasons people seek counseling in the first place.
Choice Is Often More Limited
Many experienced counselors choose not to work with insurance because of:
Low reimbursement
Heavy paperwork
Limited flexibility
That doesn’t mean in-network counselors aren’t skilled or caring. It does mean your options may be narrower.
When people pay privately, they often have more choice in finding a counselor whose style, experience, and approach truly fit.
Paying Privately Changes the Focus
Without insurance involved:
No diagnosis is required
Records stay more private
Sessions can focus on what actually matters to you
The pace and goals are set collaboratively
Instead of proving medical necessity, the work centers on clarity, understanding, and lasting change.
Counseling Is an Investment—Not Just a Service
People readily invest in:
Education
Fitness and health
Career development
Financial planning
Counseling is similar. When viewed as an investment in well-being or a relationship—rather than a medical expense—the question shifts from “What will insurance cover?” to “What kind of help will actually make a difference?”
A Clarifying Note
Insurance-based counseling isn’t bad or unethical (otherwise I wouldn’t accept insurance). For crisis situations or acute mental health needs, it can be appropriate and necessary.
The issue is assuming it’s always the best or only option.
For people and couples seeking long-term growth, deeper understanding, or relational repair, insurance often places limits that work against those goals.
A Better Question to Ask
Instead of asking, “Will insurance cover this?”
It can be helpful to ask, “What kind of support best fits what I’m actually trying to change?”
Counseling isn’t always about treating an illness. Often, it’s about learning, growth, and new ways of relating.
And those goals sometimes require stepping outside a system that was never designed to support them in the first place.So, my question to you is this: Is your relationship worth the investment with the right therapist, even if you have to pay a little more?
Be sure to click the Book A Call Button on this page to begin the consultation process.